Judge denies challenge to toss Toprani from ballot
Latest News
March 23, 2023

Judge denies challenge to toss Toprani from ballot

By Stacy Wolford

By Max Robinette
mrobinette@yourmvi.com
A Washington County judge threw out a challenge to remove a Ringgold School Board candidate from the ballot.
School board candidate Paula Harshaw announced at this month’s board meeting that she filed a petition against opponent Steve Toprani for improperly crossfiling on his ballot petition.
Toprani, a registered Republican, is listed as both a Democrat and Republican on the upcoming school board ballot.
Harshaw argued Toprani failed to get a registered Democrat to circulate his ballot petition when filing as a Democrat. Harshaw backed her claims with copies of Toprani’s ballot petitions she obtained from the county election office.
According to the Pennsylvania School Board Association, “an individual may only circulate a petition on behalf of a party of which he/she is a registered member; a registered member of the other party may circulate a petition for members of that party to request your name be on the ballot.”
Harshaw said she filed the challenge without counsel and shortly after discovering she may have improperly filed it.
Judge Michael Lucas ruled that Harshaw erred in filling the challenge as a Republican against a Democratic ballot. In Pennsylvania, a person can only file a ballot removal challenge as a member of the same party. The judge ruled that the court lacked the jurisdiction to review the challenge.

To read the rest of the story, please see a copy of Thursday’s Mon Valley Independent, call 724-314-0035 to subscribe or subscribe to our online edition at http://monvalleyindependent.com.

NextGen Alloy buys scrap metal facility
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
By SARAH PELLIS spellis@yourmvi.com 
November 16, 2026
The company purchased the West Mifflin site from Keywell Metals. A 50 year-old scrap metal facility in West Mifflin has a new owner. Founded in 2022, Latrobe- based NextGen Alloy Recycling acquired th...
LIHEAP expected to handle rising home heating costs
Latest News, Main
November 16, 2026
278,910 households statewide received LIHEAP cash benefits in 2025-26. By HALEY DAUGHERTY TribLive Officials for the state’s Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program say funding for the program is ex...
O’Neal reelected to House GOP leadership
Latest News, Main, Politics
By MICHAEL VINSICK mvinsick@yourmvi.com 
November 16, 2026
He will again serve as whip for the 2027-28 legislative session. The House Republican Caucus recently announced the re-election of state Rep. Tim O’Neal (R-Washington) to the position of its whip and ...
Missing teens found safe in Texas
Latest News, Main
By TAYLOR BROWN, Senior Reporter 
November 16, 2026
A resident tipped off law enforcement to the location of Isaac Fayson and Genevieve Welan. Two Elizabeth-area teenagers who had been missing for more than a week were found safe Saturday in Texas. Eli...
Kitchen fire in Elizabeth Borough
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
November 16, 2026
The Elizabeth Borough Volunteer Fire Company responded to a kitchen fire at a house on Church Street over the weekend. Firefighters worked quickly to contain the fire to the kitchen. Heavy smoke damag...
McKeesport Regional History & Heritage Center to host professional development day
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
By SARAH PELLIS spellis@yourmvi.com 
November 16, 2026
The McKeesport Regional History & Heritage Center, which shares the rich history of McKeesport and the surrounding Mon Valley, will host a class titled “From Local Stories to Classroom Rigor,” a socia...