Jury begins deliberating fate of accused McKeesport cop killer
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
November 21, 2026

Jury begins deliberating fate of accused McKeesport cop killer

Johnathan Morris is on trial in the death of police Officer Sean Sluganski on Feb. 6, 2023.

By PAULA REED WARD
TribLive

Johnathan Morris can’t have it both ways, the prosecutor said as she made her final pitch to the jury.

He can’t claim he didn’t know what he was doing when he fatally shot McKeesport police Officer Sean Sluganski, Emma Schoedel argued Friday, but at the same time say he was reasonably acting to defend himself.

“Both things cannot be true,” said Schoedel, an Allegheny County deputy district attorney, as she asked a jury to find Morris guilty of killing Sluganski.

But Morris’ attorney, Carmen Robinson, who argued her client should be acquitted by reason of insanity and because he acted in self-defense, disagreed.

“ Johnathan Morris did not know what he was doing,” she said during her closing argument. “In his mind, he was protecting his bodily integrity to defend himself.

“The two defenses are related. We’re asserting both.”

The jury deliberated for about an hour Friday afternoon before being released for the weekend.

They will resume Monday. Jurors will consider nine counts, including criminal homicide and murder of a law enforcement officer, as well as attempted homicide of McKeesport police Officer Charles Thomas, who was shot and wounded that day, and attempted homicide of McKeesport police Lt. Robert Eastman, who was fired upon but not injured.

During 90 minutes of instruction from Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Bruce R. Beemer, the jurors learned they would have four possible verdicts to consider for each count: guilty, not guilty, not guilty by reason of insanity, and guilty but mentally ill. They may consider only two possible forms of criminal homicide: first-degree murder, which is a killing that is willful, deliberate and premeditated; or third-degree murder, a killing with malice.

History of mental illness

Morris, 34, of McKeesport is charged with killing Sluganski, shooting Thomas and firing at Eastman on the afternoon of Feb. 6, 2023, while in the throes of a mental health crisis.

Morris’ mother, a former McKeesport police officer, called 911 just after noon that day seeking help to have her son involuntarily committed for mental health treatment. She said he was having a post-traumatic stress disorder episode.

Sluganski, 32, was the first officer to arrive at the call, with Thomas close behind. Both officers were in their own patrol vehicles.

They made a plan with Morris’ mother that she would head to UPMC McKeesport to get the commitment paperwork, while the officers would keep an eye on Morris, who was walking in the street, until then.

Over the course of about eight minutes, they followed him.

But at 12:28 p.m., while in the 1300 block of Grandview Avenue, police said Morris opened fire — first at Thomas in his police car, and less than a second later, on Sluganski, who had gotten out of his vehicle and was following on foot.

Sluganski died a short time later.

During nine days presenting its case, the prosecution called dozens of witnesses, played multiple videos and police recordings, showed maps and graphics and photographs — all depicting what happened that day.

The defense, over two days, called several of Morris’ friends and family, as well as a forensic psychologist, who described a long history of the defendant’s mental illness.

Morris has been diagnosed with bipolar disorder, schizoaffective disorder, PTSD and cannabis use disorder.

Twin defenses

Robinson began her closing argument Friday by displaying a photo of her client from his time in the Marine Corps. In it, Morris smiles widely, his eyes beaming.

“This is Johnathan Morris,” she said. “He’s still here. The smile. The pride he’s carrying with him.”

She recounted for the jury that he enlisted at 19 and later experienced a hazing incident in Afghanistan where he was locked in a closet when the base came under an unexpected mortar attack.

That incident, witnesses testified, precipitated his PTSD diagnosis and years of subsequent mental health struggles, Robinson said.

During her 80-minute argument, she told the jury her client was afraid that day in February 2023 that the police were going to kill him.

She argued that, as Thomas followed behind Morris, he drove aggressively, revving his engine. At one point, she said, her client ended up on the hood of Thomas’ car as he attempted to pin Morris against a fence.

Robinson urged the jury to find her client not guilty — either by reason of insanity or through self-defense.

To obtain a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity, the defense must show by a preponderance of the evidence that Morris did not know what he was doing that day or did not know his actions were wrong.

“It has always been our contention that Johnathan Morris suffered from persecutory delusions — that the police were going to kill him,” Robinson said.

Her client, she continued, did not know what he was doing.

To prove self-defense against a police officer, Robinson said, she must show that the officers’ actions were unlawful and that they were using deadly force against Morris — “whether Johnathan reasonably believed that the officers were trying to kill him.”

Dozens of choices

But in her closing, Schoedel told the jury that Thomas never struck Morris with his car and did not use it as a deadly weapon. Instead, Thomas’ movements with the car were “tactical.”

“He knew the police wanted to get him help that day,” Schoedel said. “He knew they weren’t trying to kill him.”

Instead, she continued, Morris opened fire on the very people trying to help him.

He acted deliberately, Schoedel said.

“It was the defendant’s bullets that blew Officer Sluganski off that hillside before he ever had a chance to draw his weapon,” she said. “The defendant fired three times at Officer Sluganski with specific intent to kill.”

As she spoke, the prosecution displayed a still photo on the screen depicting Thomas as he knelt next to his mortally wounded partner.

Thomas, who testified during the trial and watched the rest of the time from the gallery, put his head down in the back row of the courtroom and began to sob.

Schoedel, who acknowledged the defendant’s mental illness, urged the jury to dismiss Morris’ claim of legal insanity.

“Did the defendant know what he did was wrong?” she asked. “Of course he did. He knew he was shooting at police.

“He demonstrated free will and an ability to choose.”

The prosecutor said repeatedly that Morris made dozens of choices that day: He could have stopped to talk to the officers; he could have accepted help from his family; he could have run in a different direction; he could have chosen to disarm himself; he could have surrendered.

“All choices that could have led to a less-than-lethal outcome,” Schoedel said. “He was left with the choices he made, the chances he took and the opportunities he passed up.”

Explaining possible verdicts

During his closing instruction to the jurors, Beemer defined the legal definition of insanity and the difference between that and a finding of guilty but mentally ill.

Legal insanity, Beemer said, means that a person is “sick rather than bad” and that a defendant “does not deserve to be blamed and treated like a criminal for what he did.”

That finding, he continued, excuses any crime, including murder. To be found not guilty by reason of insanity, a defendant must show his mental illness prohibited him from knowing “the nature and quality of the act he was doing” or that what he was doing was wrong.

A verdict of guilty but mentally ill, a lesser finding, requires a defendant to show that, as a result of mental illness, he “lacks substantial capacity either to appreciate the wrongfulness of his conduct or to conform his conduct to the requirements of the law.”

If the jury were to find Morris not guilty by reason of insanity, Beemer said, the court would begin immediate proceedings to determine if he should be committed to a mental health facility.

If the jury finds Morris guilty but mentally ill, he would be required to receive mental health treatment during any incarceration.

Monongahela welcomes holidays with Merry and Bright Night
Latest News, Main
November 21, 2026
A warm evening boosted the turnout for the city’s annual celebration. Story by MVI Staff Writer Michael Vinsick mvinsick@yourmvi.com *** Photos by MVI Staff Photographer Jeff Helsel jhelsel@yourmvi.co...
Holidays to kick off this weekend in North Belle Vernon
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
November 21, 2026
By the MVI The holidays have grown in North Belle Vernon, with festivities set for this weekend. The schedule will run as follows: • Today – Christmas on the Avenue — Shop local businesses starting at...
Property tax hike, layoffs in tentative 2027 budget
Latest News, Main
CHARLEROI
By TAYLOR BROWN, Senior Reporter 
November 21, 2026
Rising costs and the closing of businesses in the borough created additional budgetary strain. Higher property taxes and possible job cuts could be on the horizon in Charleroi as borough officials wor...
Monongahela Elks support Finleyville Food Pantry
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
November 21, 2026
Monongahela Elks Lodge No. 455 received a grant through the Elks National Foundation (ENF) to purchase $4,000 in hams to donate to the Finleyville Food Pantry located at 406 Chess St. in Monongahela. ...
In Pa., a teacher’s pay depends on where the job is
Latest News, Main, News
November 21, 2026
By Namira Haris, NewsWorks Lab November 5, 2026 NewsWorks Lab NewsWorks Lab is a public-benefit company owned by Trib Total Media to produce high-impact, accountability journalism as a free, open-sour...