Defense attorneys for accused cop killer call a slew of witnesses in support of ‘legally insane’ claim
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
November 19, 2026

Defense attorneys for accused cop killer call a slew of witnesses in support of ‘legally insane’ claim

The defense expert said Johnathan Morris did not know his actions were wrong the day police said he shot and killed Officer Sean Sluganski.

By PAULA REED WARD
TribLive

Defense attorneys for the man accused of killing McKeesport police Officer Sean Sluganski on Wednesday called witness after witness whose testimony bolstered their claims that Johnathan Morris had long experienced mental illness and was legally insane at the time of the shooting.

Morris’ ex-fiancee and ex-wife, as well as a longtime friend he met in the U.S. Marine Corps, all described multiple instances in which he exhibited paranoia, delusions and night terrors dating back years.

Testimony centering on Morris’ mental illness culminated with a forensic psychologist who said that the defendant, on the day Sluganski was killed on Feb. 6, 2023, “did not know the nature and quality of his actions.

“His mental illness prevented him from knowing what he was doing was wrong,” said Dr. Terri Dilmore.

She told the jury Morris met the legal definition for “insanity” under Pennsylvania law.

Dilmore’s testimony is expected to be countered by a psychiatrist slated to be called by the prosecution on Thursday.

Morris’ attorneys said they would argue to the jury that Morris is not guilty by reason of insanity and that his shooting of the officers that day was in self-defense.

Morris, 34, is charged with criminal homicide and murder of a law enforcement officer in Sluganski’s death, as well as attempted homicide for shooting and wounding McKeesport Officer Charles Thomas, and shooting at, but missing, Lt. Robert Eastman.

His trial began on Nov. 9 before Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer. The judge said it’s possible testimony in the case concludes on Thursday. Police said Morris opened fire on Sluganski and Thomas as they followed him along the streets of McKeesport, hoping to convince him to go get mental health treatment.

‘He was always afraid’

The defense began its case in earnest Wednesday, calling a series of Morris’ loved ones to describe how he changed following a monthslong deployment to Afghanistan.

Morris’ ex-wife, Anais Badnell, who also served in the Marines, told the jury the two of them got married in 2012. When they first got together, she said, Morris was a happy, active and healthy person.

That changed when he returned from Afghanistan.

“Instantly, when he came home, I could tell a difference,” she said.”Before, he was full of joy.”

Badnell testified that Morris became paranoid, sad and worried. But, she continued, he wouldn’t tell her what was wrong.

“He would hide under the bed.” Dilmore told the jury that Morris’ military records show that when he was in Afghanistan, he was locked inside a closet on base when there was a mortar attack. The defense has said that contributed to his PTSD.

Emilio Perez, who served in the U.S. Marine Corps with Morris in Maryland, said the two met in 2015 and later became roommates. He often heard Morris in the middle of the night experiencing night terrors. He described Morris frequently shivering and wrestling in his sleep and then waking up out of breath.

During that time, too, Morris hated loud and startling noises, Perez said.

The two worked as part of a biological response force that deployed to emergencies and catastrophic events stateside, Perez said. However, he noted that it took Morris longer to complete the training program for their unit, in part, he said, because Morris was afraid of confined spaces.

After they were both discharged in 2018, Perez said that he and Morris remained friends. But as the years wore on, Morris became paranoid, Perez said, accusing him of sleeping with his girlfriend and calling his daughter derogatory names.

Morris’ ex-fiancee, Arylin Ballesteros, also described his ongoing paranoia.

Ballesteros, an attorney, said that she and Morris met at a Starbucks in San Diego, California, in 2019, and later moved to Florida so they could be closer to his daughter. When they first met, she said, Morris was charismatic.

“Toward the end, he was a completely different person,” she said. “He was always afraid.”

During the time they were together, Ballesteros said that Morris frequently didn’t sleep at night, and when he did, he would wake up with nightmares, sweating and yelling — unable to recognize her.

“Sometimes he would be so afraid, he would lay on the floor,” she said.

Ballesteros testified that Morris would hang blankets over their doors and windows because he felt threatened. He was suspicious of people, including her.

“Sometimes, he would think I was poisoning his food,” Ballesteros said.

She told the jury on cross-examination that Morris had delusions that the police were trying to kill him. At one point while in Florida, Ballesteros said she asked the police to have Morris involuntarily committed for mental health treatment, but they refused.

“They said he needed to be suicidal to take him in,” she said.

Ballesteros told the jury that she tried to make Morris get help, but he often turned to meditation, religion and self-help books.

“He tried to fight it on his own,” she said.

During one incident, Ballesteros said Morris thought that their home was being invaded, so he called the police.

“He’s running around our house trying to catch the person, but there was no one there,” she said.

Morris’ cousin, Kiatta Jones, who lives in Atlanta, told the jury that she got a call in October 2022 to go pick her cousin up — five hours away in Florida — because he was in a panic, thinking the police were chasing him and trying to kill him.

He gave her the address of a gas station where he would be, and when she arrived, “he came out of the bushes,” with a T-shirt tied around his face like a ninja.

Morris was paranoid, she said, and wouldn’t speak out loud, instead, writing messages on his phone for her to read, telling her to be quiet.

“‘They are listening to us,’” he wrote.

‘Psychosis and mania’

Dilmore, the expert in forensic psychology retained by the defense, spent about three hours on the witness stand.

She told the jury she interviewed Morris six times, including five in person and one virtually.

In addition, Dilmore testified that she reviewed all of the discovery in the case, video evidence, Morris’ military, medical and mental health records, as well as information from his time at Torrance State Hospital and at the Allegheny County Jail following his arrest.

Dilmore told the jury that Morris’ records were replete with evidence dating back to his time in the Marine Corps of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. He’d previously been diagnosed with a significant startle response, “hyper arousal,” and a significant sleep disorder.

Morris, Dilmore continued, experienced mania and depression and psychosis, along with hallucinations and delusions.

At the time of the shooting, she said, he was suffering from persecutory delusions.

“There was a perceived threat by Mr. Morris he was in imminent danger and was fleeing in an attempt to survive what he perceived was a threat to his life.

“To them, it feels real.” Morris, she said, had a lack of insight into his own mental health.

“You don’t know you’re experiencing a delusion,” Dilmore said, which makes it difficult to read environmental cues. “His mental illness prevented him from knowing what he was doing was wrong.”

During cross-examination, Allegheny County Deputy District Attorney Ryan Kiray pressed Dilmore on Morris’ non-compliance with mental health treatment dating back to his time in the Marines — he said Morris missed more appointments than he attended. He also questioned Dilmore whether the defendant’s failure to recall some of the events of that day showed selective memory.

She disagreed. “Memories wax and wane,” Dilmore said. “It’s a function of psychosis and mania.”

Morris, she continued, could not appreciate the wrongfulness of his conduct.

But, Kiray countered, the defendant apologized for what happened in a police interview.

“Apologizing can indicate an awareness you’ve done something wrong?” the prosecutor asked.

“Yes and no,” Dilmore answered. Kiray concluded his cross-examination pointing out a discrepancy between Dilmore’s testimony in court and her written expert report. Although she testified using the legal definition of insanity, in her report, she wrote that Morris met the legal standard for guilty but mentally ill — a lesser finding that does not provide the same legal relief for a defendant.

Nice day to visit Palmer park
Latest News, Main
November 19, 2026
Ralph Turkovich of Donora enjoys a quiet Wednesday morning at Palmer Park with his white Maltese, Trixie, after the pair took a walk along the Donora park’s trail. Back in the driver’s seat of his pic...
BVA leader to provide update on elementary school project
Latest News, Main
By MICHAEL VINSICK mvinsick@yourmvi.com 
November 19, 2026
Superintendent Dr. Timothy Glasspool said they are trying to limit the impact on taxpayers Belle Vernon Area School District leaders are expected to give an update on the current options and costs ass...
Time to get ‘merry and bright’ as Monongahela is set to usher in the holidays
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
November 19, 2026
The Monongahela Area Chamber of Commerce welcomes the community to come eat, drink, shop, listen to music and get in the holiday spirit at Friday’s event. By the MVI Merry and Bright Night will kick o...
Mon Valley Memorial Park under new ownership
Latest News, Main
By TAYLOR BROWN, Senior Reporter 
November 19, 2026
The Donora property’s sale was finalized Nov. 10. For more than 80 years, Mon Valley Memorial Park in Donora has been a final resting place for generations of families throughout the region. Now, the ...
Future of former Rite Aid property concerns mayor
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
WEST MIFFLIN BOROUGH
November 19, 2026
Mayor Chris Kelly is worried about access to the Mitchell Paige Memorial Park. By THOMAS LETURGEY For the MVI The future of a veterans memorial is uncertain as access to it hinges on the next owner of...