Jury sees video of police interview with accused McKeesport cop killer
‘I must’ve blacked out for real,’ Johnathan Morris told detectives days after Officer Sean Sluganski died.
By PAULA REED WARD
TribLive
When Allegheny County Police detectives arrived in Johnathan Morris’ hospital room three days after they said he shot and killed a McKeesport police officer, he was calm and cooperative.
He recounted what he said he remembered from Feb. 6, 2023, including being followed by the police.
But when confronted by Det. Patrick Kinavey that he fired at three police officers that day, he vacillated between disbelieving and apologetic.
At first, when Kinavey told Morris he’d shot at them, Morris responded: “I’m sorry about that,” before making the sign of the cross.
When told he killed Officer Sean Sluganski, Morris responded, “Damn,” putting his head down. Then, “There would be no way possible I shot a cop.”
Instead, Morris continued, he fired that day into a police car — calling them warning shots.
“I’m telling you, 100%, you did,” Kinavey responded. “It’s on video.”
“I didn’t shoot at him,” Morris continued. “Literally, I did not.”
He added, “I must’ve blacked out for real.”
“Damn.” As the interview wound down, Morris continued, “I apologize for all this.”
With his head in his hands, hiding his eyes, he said. “I’m sorry for that cop’s family.”
The nearly 30-minute video of Morris’ interview — with a small pixelated box obscuring his right hand that was cuffed to the hospital bed — was played for the jury on Tuesday, his sixth day of trial.
A short time later, the prosecution rested its case.
Morris is charged with criminal homicide and murder of a law enforcement officer in the death of Sluganski, and attempted homicide for the shooting of Officer Charles Thomas. His trial began Nov. 9 before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer and is expected to last through the end of the month.
During opening statements, Morris’ attorney, Carmen Robinson, told the jury she would present ev-idence of both self-defense and insanity.
The defense presentation was expected to begin Tuesday afternoon.
‘I’m no criminal’
When Morris first started talking to detectives the morning of Feb. 9, 2023, he told them the day of the shooting had started out as a good morning.
He didn’t know that his mom had called 911 seeking to have her son involuntarily committed for mental health treatment until Kinavey told him.
What he did know, he continued, was that when he went to leave his house that day, his satchel was missing. He told detectives he believed his family was stealing from him.
Morris left the house and said he later saw a police car pull up behind him. The officer inside said, “‘You’re coming with us.’” “‘I haven’t done anything wrong,’” Morris said he replied. “‘I’m just going to buy a fish tank.’” He continued walking, although in recounting the story to detectives, he said he must have blacked out, only coming to some time later when he realized he’d dropped his cell phone.
By that point, Morris said, he was running from the officers.
“These people are still following me,” he said. “‘I’m a Marine, dude. I served my country. I’m no criminal,’” he told them.
Warning shots?
Morris said he must have blacked out again — when he came to that time, he said he was on top of a police car.
“I hop off the car, try to run away from the car, almost get smashed by the patrol car,” he said.
Moments later, he said he saw one of the officers following him pull a gun.
“I pull out my pistol, fire mine twice,” he said. “I’m scared, man.”
Later, he said they were “just warning shots.”
“I turn around, start running. I notice I’m hurt.”
Morris saw blood trickling down his leg.
It was then, police said, that Morris got to the intersection of Patterson Street and Versailles Avenue where he collapsed and spoke to two men working in the area.
He asked them for help, and as they assisted him, another McKeesport police officer, responding to Thomas’ radio calls that an officer was down, pulled up.
Lt. Robert Eastman approached, Morris said in the video, and he saw the officer draw his weapon. Morris told Kinavey he thought he was going to die, so he pulled his weapon from his lap and fired.
Eastman, who testified earlier in the week, returned fire, emptying his service weapon, as Morris barrel- rolled into the intersection.
Morris, video showed, slid his 9 mm pistol across the road and gave himself up.
Video evidence
During his interview with Kinavey, Morris was unable to recall the type of gun he had, but knew it was a 9 mm and that it held seven rounds.
He also remembered that he bought it in Georgia.
As he recounted the events of that day, Morris did not include having spoken to two women in a car that was passing by.
When Kinavey reminded him, Morris quickly picked up the details of their interaction.
“They told me to get inside the vehicle to get me out of McKeesport,” he recalled.
Morris remembered being afraid of the police but also not wanting to get in the women’s car.
“‘Can you just record it? Just follow me in your car, and make sure I’m OK,’” he told them.
They did, capturing footage of Sluganski and Thomas as they followed Morris on much of the route they took that day over six-tenths of a mile.
The women testified earlier in the trial that Morris appeared to be having a mental health crisis at the time.
No apparent confusion
Those mental health concerns were a main focus when Morris’ defense attorney cross-examined Kinavey on Tuesday.
Robinson repeatedly asked the detective if he was concerned about her client’s mental health as he interviewed him in his hospital bed.
“When we spoke to him, he was clearly clear-headed,” the detective answered.
“Didn’t it appear Johnathan was confused about the facts of the day?” Robinson asked.
“I don’t believe so,” Kinavey responded. “He was answering questions as I posed to him.”
The prosecution concluded its case with evidence showing that Morris did not have a valid Pennsylvania permit to carry a concealed weapon at the time of the shooting.
Over the first six days of trial, the district attorney’s office called approximately three dozen witnesses.