‘It just hasn’t been long enough’: Family’s pain rushes back as Jobeth Olson’s killer approaches parole eligibility
Latest News, Main, News
October 28, 2026

‘It just hasn’t been long enough’: Family’s pain rushes back as Jobeth Olson’s killer approaches parole eligibility

By PAULA REED WARD
TribLive

Retired Allegheny County prosecutor Lisa Pellegrini tried dozens of homicide cases over the course of her 30-year career.

But one verdict, she said, continues to haunt her.

Pellegrini described Jobeth Olson as a sweet, young woman who in 2006 fell under the influence of a manipulative, more experienced man four years her senior.

James Nalls was accused of assaulting Olson when she was 31 weeks pregnant with his child. Then, months later, police said he shot and killed the 19-year-old Olson moments after the two left an Applebee’s restaurant in West Mifflin.

Their daughter was 6 months old.

Pellegrini, a member of the district attorney’s homicide unit, took the case to trial in the summer of 2008. She believed Olson’s death was an execution and that evidence she presented was more than enough to convict Nalls of first-degree murder.

Nalls, who lived in West Mifflin, testified at trial that the shooting was accidental. He said Olson pointed a gun at him, he grabbed it, and it went off as he tried to wrestle the weapon away.

The jury returned what appeared to be a compromise verdict, finding the former Navy sailor guilty of third-degree murder. At his sentencing in September 2008, Nalls received the maximum possible punishment — 20 to 40 years in state prison.

“He was one of the most manipulative defendants I’ve ever had,” Pellegrini said. “She had a bright future ahead of her, but she just couldn’t untangle herself from him — and that’s what domestic abusers do.”

Over the summer, Jobeth’s mother, Amy Olson, received a letter from the state Office of Victim Advocate informing her that Nalls would reach his minimum sentence and become eligible for parole on April 6, 2027.

“When I got that envelope in August, my heart fell to the floor,” Amy Olson said. “For 20 years, I didn’t have to think about him. He didn’t exist.”

Now, the family is planning their testimony to the Pennsylvania Parole Board next month and collecting signatures on a change.org petition urging the panel to deny Nalls’ release.

“I remember (thinking) this, and it sounds so arrogant now, ‘He’s going to be an old man before he gets out,’” Pellegrini said.

Should Nalls be paroled on his first consideration in the spring, he would be 44. At that age, the Olson family said, they believe he could still be a threat.

“That’s still young, still this whole life ahead of him,” said Mary Olson, Jobeth’s younger sister. “I believe we owe it to future women.”

But Nalls’ sister sees a man who has changed and is ready to be released.

“I don’t see my brother’s story as one in which there was once a bad person and now there is a good person,” Gina Orban said. “Human beings are more complicated than that. What I can say with complete honesty is that he is a better man today.

“He has matured, gained perspective and worked very hard to make something meaningful of the years he has spent incarcerated.”

On-again, off-again

Jobeth Olson was a freshman at the University of Pittsburgh majoring in communications when she learned she was pregnant.

She decided to take a year off to have the baby and expected to return to her studies for the fall 2007 semester.

Olson’s relationship with Nalls was fraught. He admitted at trial to cheating on her with multiple women, and they were frequently onagain, off-again.

In August 2006, Olson told police Nalls assaulted her at his home when she went there to retrieve her belongings. They filed simple assault charges, and she sought a Protection From Abuse order against him.

However, the PFA lapsed, and the two mended their relationship. Nalls said it was Olson who acted out that day, and he physically carried her out of his home when she refused to leave. He denied assaulting her.

Their daughter Jayla was born that fall.

On March 30, 2007, Olson went out with a friend, leaving Jayla overnight with her parents. When Olson returned to her house just down the street from her parents early the next morning, her family said, the lights wouldn’t turn on.

Olson’s friend testified at trial that Olson called her later that morning and told her Nalls had been inside waiting for her. She said he beat her — claims he denied at trial.

A few days later, when Nalls arrived at the Eat n’ Park restaurant in Whitehall where Olson worked, she agreed to talk with him and go with him to Applebee’s.

Olson’s sister, Mary, also worked at the Eat n’ Park restaurant along Route 51. She was the last person in their family to see Jobeth alive.

“I watched her walk out, and she said, ‘Bye, Mare.’” A few hours later, after their dad came to pick up Mary from work, the two of them were traveling home along Route 885 near Century III Mall when she said she saw three ambulances speed past.

“I remember looking at my dad and saying, ‘Oh my gosh, I wonder where they’re going?’”

A murder case?

The ambulances were heading to the intersection of Route 885 and Delwar Road, where they’d been called to a reported shooting.

According to testimony at trial, Olson and Nalls arrived at Applebee’s around 8:20 p.m. on April 2, 2007, and ordered their food. Although employees said everything appeared to be fine between them at first, as the evening progressed, Olson’s mood changed. She became quiet, and just before 9:30 p.m., she asked for their meals to be wrapped up. They left.

Seven minutes later, Nalls called 911 to report a shooting.

At first, Nalls told police that a group of men in a white car had pulled up next to Olson’s minivan and fired at her in a road rage incident.

Throughout that night at the scene and later at the police station, Nalls’ story changed repeatedly. Olson died the next morning at UPMC Presbyterian in Oakland.

When police asked if he would agree to a gunshot residue test, Nalls said yes but added that he’d been at a gun range that day — which later proved to be untrue.

Eventually, at trial, Nalls told the jury that as they left the restaurant, he and Olson argued, and she wouldn’t let him in the minivan. Then when he opened the passenger- side door, he claimed Olson had his own gun pointed at him.

Nalls claimed he left his firearm — which he had a permit to carry — in the center console of Olson’s minivan.

He testified that he grabbed the weapon, pushed it back and tried to pull it out of her hands. A prosecution witness testified that he was in a nearby parking lot during the incident and saw a man half in the passenger side of the vehicle appearing to wrestle with the driver.

Within seconds, the gun went off. The minivan then rolled slowly through the intersection, coming to a rest in the Goodyear Tire parking lot across the street.

At trial, Pellegrini painted a wholly different story. She told the jury that Nalls shot Olson “point blank in the back of the head.”

As the police continued to investigate, she said, they learned that “all of the things that the defendant told them were impossible.”

Pellegrini also presented evidence of Nalls’ “prior bad acts” against Olson, including the incident when she was pregnant and the one the few days before she was killed.

The prosecutor also got Nalls to admit on cross-examination to lying dozens of times during the course of the investigation.

Nalls’ defense attorney, William Difenderfer, told the jury that his client panicked at the scene that night. But, he argued, that doesn’t mean he killed Olson on purpose.

Difenderfer noted that Nalls called 911 immediately that night.

“He is not trying to run away. He is not trying to evade or in any way (do) anything that would resemble any planning here,” Difenderfer said, according to the trial transcript. “It’s ludicrous to think that this ever was planned.”

He told the jury that after the shooting, Nalls took the gun and threw it up the hillside behind the crime scene out of panic.

“Murderers don’t stick around. Murderers don’t allow the person to leave hoping they are going to live,” Difenderfer said. “Murderers kill and leave and try to get away it.”

“This isn’t a murder case. These people were in love.”

After the jury returned its verdict, Nalls was ordered to serve the maximum possible sentence for third-degree murder — 20 to 40 years.

Following his conviction, he filed a series of unsuccessful appeals, both in state court, and later on his own in federal court.

Nalls argued that he was denied due process — both when the trial judge denied his request to call an expert to testify that the gun discharged accidentally, and when the court allowed the prosecution to present evidence of the “prior bad acts.”

Further, he argued that third-degree murder should not have applied in his case.

“The death of Ms. Olson was tragic, but it was not the result of a malicious killing,” he wrote on his own behalf. “The situation was an unfortunate combination of two young people involved in a rocky relationship plagued with infidelity and distrust that ended in a terrible moment in the confines of a minivan.”

‘It just hasn’t been long enough’

Olson, her family said, was loyal and funny and had a big personality that could own a room. She played soccer and basketball at West Mifflin Area High School.

She had a raspy voice, was a great storyteller and dreamed of being a television newscaster.

Olson only wanted one slice of cheese on her grilled cheese sandwiches, enjoyed music, had a collection of sneakers that she kept in immaculate condition and made the people around her feel good.

At 19, Olson was still trying to figure herself out, according to her sister, Annie Kaib.

“You’re allowed to make mistakes and mature and become that person you’re going to be at 30,” she said. “She was robbed of her chance.”

Olson also loved her daughter fiercely, her family said.

After her mother’s death, Jayla was raised by her grandparents, aunts and uncle.

She is now 20 — older than her mom was when she was killed.

Amy Olson said that after her daughter was killed, she made it her mission to ensure that Jayla had a loving, normal upbringing and that her family stayed together and strong.

She said they relied on their faith and made sure that Jobeth’s life remained a part of theirs.

“You learn you have to hold onto her in different ways,” Amy Olson said.

They celebrated Jobeth’s birthday each year. She was a presence at her sisters’ weddings. Her nieces and nephews know the stories about her.

“We openly would just share things all the time,” Mary Olson said. “Our kids know — it’s like she’s still Aunt Jobeth.”

But the family desperately wishes they could have seen how Olson would have raised Jayla — the type of mother she would have been to the baby she called “Chunk-abutts.”

Jayla has not had a relationship with Nalls. And now, her family fears what could happen if he gets released.

“The violence that ended Jobeth’s life did not begin on the day she was murdered. Before her death, there was a pattern of manipulation, control and escalating violence,” they wrote in their petition, which has garnered nearly 4,000 signatures. “It was a gradual breaking down of a woman who was strong-willed, fiercely loyal and deeply loving, using some of the very qualities that made her who she was against her.”

The Olsons wrote that their efforts to stop Nalls from getting paroled are not about revenge.

“This is not us just sitting here hating him and wanting revenge,” Mary Olson said. “It just hasn’t been long enough.”

The family acknowledges that two decades have passed.

”We understand that the passage of time is part of the parole process. But time does not make this crime less serious, restore the future Jobeth lost or erase our concerns about what his release could mean for Jayla and others.”

‘Information is important’

John Rago, a law professor at the Thomas R. Kline School of Law at Duquesne University, said the point of parole is to allow for the reintegration of an offender into society, while at the same time maintaining a level of accountability to protect public safety.

The process can be long and tedious — both for the offender seeking parole, and for the people who were victimized.

Pennie Hockenberry, Pennsylvania’s acting victim advocate, said that for surviving family members, getting the notice of a parole hearing “rips it all open.”

“It’s something you have to process and work through,” she said.

The state Office of Victim Advocate sends letters like the one the Olsons received early to give families as much advance notice as possible to decide how they want to respond, Hockenberry said.

While some victims and families may not want to participate in the process, many do.

That can range from submitting written statements, petitions or video or audio recordings to testifying in person.

“You name it, we’ve gotten it,” Hockenberry continued. “It’s a way to honor the person they’ve lost. (It’s a way to tell the board) ‘This is not a statistic.’” Generally, she said, the family wants to create a multidimensional picture of the person they lost.

The victim impact information provided to the board is confidential and does not go to the offender, Hockenberry said.

Rago, who also serves on Pennsylvania’s Commission on Sentencing, said it is consequential.

But it’s just one part of the information the board reviews.

The parole process begins within the state Department of Corrections, Rago said.

The department completes its own evaluations, looking at the offender’s history of disciplinary misconducts, how they adjusted to prison, their level of program participation and their work assignments.

They also conduct an assessment to identify areas of possible need, the likelihood of reoffending and the potential for success upon release.

Rago said factors weighed during the assessment include criminal history, education, employment, family relationships, substance abuse, peer associations, attitudes toward criminal behavior and recreational activities.

While an assessment “does not determine an individual’s future behavior with certainty,” Rago said, “it’s not subjective. It’s not arbitrary. Information is important.”

Once the Department of Corrections has compiled that information, it will make a recommendation on release to the parole board, which Rago said then begins its work.

The board receives victim input, including family statements that address the continuing impact of the crime, safety concerns and their position on release.

The parole board also completes an extensive review of the case, as well as the offender’s record. The members interview the offender, as well.

To earn parole in a third-degree murder case, Rago said five of the board’s nine members must vote in favor of release.

The board can grant parole with conditions or deny it for future consideration. In third-degree murder cases where parole is denied, state law allows an offender to reapply every three years until they are released.

Whatever the decision, the board is required to issue a short statement explaining its decision.

Rago said serving the minimum sentence does not guarantee release.

“I don’t think people should assume first release is automatic, because it’s not,” he said. “There is no rubber stamp. There’s no preset agenda. There’s no quota for a number of people who have to be let out.”

Instead, Rago said the board weighs public safety, the incarcerated person’s demonstrated change and the likelihood of successful supervision.

‘I’ve done everything I can do’

Orban, Nalls’ sister, believes those factors weigh in her brother’s favor.

During his incarceration, Orban said her brother has completed programs focused on victims and accountability and earned certifications in HVAC work and personal training. He worked on the HVAC crew at SCI Somerset and led workout classes in the prison gym.

Orban said Nalls also served on the board of SOAR. The group, led by incarcerated people, raises money for local charities and was recognized by the Make-A-Wish Foundation for its work.

Orban said her brother has a passion for helping others.

“To me, these accomplishments matter not simply because he completed them, but because they reflect who he truly is and how he has chosen to use his time while incarcerated,” Orban said. “To James, however, these accomplishments pale in comparison with the life that was lost.”

Nalls, now being held at the State Correctional Institution at Coal Township, Northumberland County, said by phone that he has spent his time learning about accountability and coming to fully understand the gravity of his choices — not just on the night Olson was killed but leading up to it.

Those choices, he said, “shattered lives, dreams and aspirations, and the ripple effect is further than anyone could ever imagine,” Nalls told TribLive.

“I understand I can never fully make amends for the loss of Jobeth’s life, the pain I’ve caused the Olson family, and even more unimaginable, the pain I caused my daughter Jayla,” he added.

Nalls said he is remorseful. “I believe that true remorse doesn’t diminish with time, it grows,” he said. “It sits on your soul, on your conscience, and that is what drives me.”

Nalls, who would like to someday open his own gym and work with troubled youth, believes he is ready to be paroled.

“I’ve done everything I can do,” he said. “I hope that the board believes I earned parole and a chance at redemption.”

Orban knows that her brother’s life will carry both opportunities and responsibilities when he is eventually released.

“We do not expect anyone to forget the past. We know that we never will,” Orban said. “I simply hope he is given the chance to be seen as the whole person he is today, rather than defined solely by one chapter of his life.”

Halloween fun at parades in Charleroi, Monongahela
Latest News, Main
October 29, 2026
The great fall weather brought large crowds to the annual Halloween parades in downtown Charleroi and at the Monongahela Area Chamber of Commerce Halloween parade Wednesday night. Monongahela photos b...
Kuzma to face challenger Altemara in reelection bid for 39th district
Allegheny County Elections, Elections, Latest News, ...
By SARAH PELLIS spellis@yourmvi.com 
October 29, 2026
Republican Andrew Kuzma is seeking his third term in office. State Rep. Andrew Kuzma will face Democratic challenger Dylan Altemara in his reelection bid to represent the 39th Legislative District. Ku...
Shapiro’s pivot: Where Pennsylvania’s major data center projects stand now
Elections, Latest News, Main, ...
October 29, 2026
NewsWorks Lab is an independent nonprofit newsroom. Sign up for our free newsletters. Growing voter opposition prompts policy shift, but none of the once-expedited data centers have signed onto new st...
Direction of Pa. measles outbreak ‘promising,’ health secretary says
Latest News, Main
October 29, 2026
Only two cases have so far been confirmed in Allegheny County, where vaccination efforts have grown. By JAMES ENGEL TribLive Pennsylvania health secretary Dr. Debra Bogen said recent drops in the numb...
Hallween Pet costume contest held in West Mifflin
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
October 29, 2026
Casey Squires presents her cat Thea as a bumblebee to West Mifflin Borough council members and guest judges A.J. Olasz and Mike Moses during West Mifflin Community Foundation’s inaugural Halloween Pet...
Clairton council addresses bank building, hears from residents
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
October 29, 2026
Council also heard from several residents at the meeting. By THOMAS LETURGEY For the MVI Clairton’s Legislative Council meeting Tuesday night focused a lot on the youth of the city, the condition of s...