Suspect in December murder faces death penalty
Latest News
March 15, 2021

Suspect in December murder faces death penalty

By Mon Valley Independent

By KRISTIE LINDEN

klinden@yourmvi.com

The Coal Center man who is charged with the stabbing death of his neighbor in December will face the death penalty if convicted.

Washington County’s First Assistant District Attorney Jason Walsh notified Dylan Lesnik, 29, of Spring Street that he is eligible for the death penalty if convicted in the Dec. 18 murder of 27-year-old Marshall Craig.

Lesnik is charged with homicide, theft and abuse of a corpse. 

During his formal arraignment Monday, Lesnik was notified of two aggravating circumstances that made his case eligible for the death penalty — that the murder allegedly happened during the commission of another felony and was done by means of torture. 

Walsh said there are two felonies Lesnik is accused of committing during the murder, burglary/robbery and aggravated assault. Lesnik is accused of torturing Craig by repeatedly stabbing him, both before and after his death.

Craig’s murder came at the end of a week in which Lesnik had been on the run after allegedly assaulting his pregnant girlfriend Cassie King.

Lesnik and his friend, Troy Chiera, 34, of Brownsville, recorded King, who was nine weeks pregnant, as she was on the ground bleeding, telling her to say her ex-boyfriend assaulted her, police said. 

King allegedly told police Lesnik said he was going to kill her while he was assaulting her and she grabbed a knife in self defense. Instead, police said, Lesnik grabbed the knife and attempted to stab King in the stomach with it, and slashed across her face and neck.

While she was bleeding and attempting to get downstairs on her own, Chiera entered the home and told King he was an EMT, police said. Chiera allegedly advised Lesnik to get rid of the knife and then the pair of men recorded her while telling her to say her ex-boyfriend “did this to her,” the complaint states.  

The men allegedly fled together and King was treated for a severed artery in her neck and a broken bone in her spinal cord.

To read the rest of the story, please see a copy of Monday’s Mon Valley Independent, call 724-314-0035 to subscribe or subscribe to our online edition at http://monvalleyindependent.com.

Monessen Police Host Night Out
Latest News, Main
June 25, 2026
Monessen police Officer Mike Piccini presents police department cups, coloring books and Child ID kits to Raegan Livingston, 7, of Monessen, during Monessen Night Out on Wednesday evening at Monessen ...
McKeesport coach resigns; Smith hired
Latest News, Main
2 00
By LADIMIR GARCIA lgarcia@yourmvi.com 
June 25, 2026
The school board voted to accept his resignation during a special meeting Wednesday and hired Tom Smith as the head high school football coach. The McKeesport Area School Board accepted the resignatio...
No tax increase in new Charleroi Area budget
Latest News, Main
June 25, 2026
District officials cited “years of careful planning” helped the board deliver a balanced budget with no property tax hike. For the MVI The Charleroi Area School District Board of Directors approved a ...
Amid packed crowd, EF delays budget vote; hears from teachers over contract negotiations
Latest News, Main
By By SARAH PELLIS spellis@gmail.com 
June 25, 2026
The Elizabeth Forward School Board moved the meeting to the middle school auditorium to accommodate the crowd. In front of a packed crowd, the Elizabeth Forward School Board tabled voting on the 2026-...
McKeesport police hear from residents at community event
Around The Valley, Latest News
By By THOMAS LETURGEY For the MVI 
June 25, 2026
About 20 residents attended the community outreach at First Step Recovery Homes. The McKeesport Police Department hosted its second “Your Presence Matters” community meeting Tuesday night at the First...
BVA’s Dusi, Kent shine at New Balance Nationals
High school, Sports
By JEREMY SELLEW 
June 25, 2026
The New Balance Outdoor National Championships were held at the University of Pennsylvania last weekend. A pair of local athletes had the privilege of participating in a prestigious track and field ev...