Judge: Sunshine Act was violated
Latest News
December 17, 2020

Judge: Sunshine Act was violated

By Mon Valley Independent

By KRISTIE LINDEN

klinden@yourmvi.com

Mayor Matt Shorraw and Monessen City Council violated the Sunshine Act twice in January, but did not do so willfully or wantonly, according to a Westmoreland County judge.

Common Pleas Court Judge Harry Smail Jr. issued his ruling in the lawsuit filed by the Mon Valley Independent and city resident Tina O’Dell against Shorraw and Monessen that found partially in favor of both parties.

The Pennsylvania Sunshine Act requires government agencies to take official action in open, public meetings that the public can attend and where they can participate before the action is taken.

Smail ruled that the city and Shorraw violated the Sunshine Act at the Jan. 6 reorganization council meeting and found that it likely happened again at a meeting Jan. 29 when council voted to ratify the motions passed at the earlier meeting.

For that initial violation, the city and Shorraw are ordered to comply with all provisions of the state Sunshine Act in any and all future proceedings and are further ordered to attend Sunshine Act training through the state’s Office of Open Records within 30 days. 

“As the Mon Valley’s local newspaper, it is our job as journalists to be a watchdog over local government,” said Stacy Wolford, managing editor of the Mon Valley Independent. “We believe government should be open and transparent, and we filed this lawsuit for the public’s right to know and to ensure that the Sunshine Act is upheld. We are grateful Judge Smail agreed with us.” 

To read the rest of the story, please see a copy of Friday’s Mon Valley Independent, call 724-314-0035 to subscribe or subscribe to our online edition at http://monvalleyindependent.com.

Clairton band brings out the Bears
Latest News, Main
November 14, 2026
The Clairton High School marching band performs as the Bears football team takes the field before kickoff of Friday’s WPIAL Class 1A quarterfinal matchup with California at Russ Grimm Field at Southmo...
California company destroyed by fire
Latest News, Main
November 14, 2026
No injuries were reported in the Maund Industries blaze, but the building and the equipment inside were ruled a total loss. By the MVI A massive fire and multiple explosions Thursday night destroyed M...
Plans unveiled for ‘McKeesport Tomorrow’ project
Latest News, Main
By By THOMAS LETURGEY For the MVI 
November 14, 2026
It includes strong investment along the city’s riverside. In November 2025, McKeesport leaders and representatives from The Collaborative, an urban planning organization from Boston, started talking w...
Donora approves sale and demolition of properties
Around The Valley, Latest News, Main
By MICHAEL VINSICK mvinsick@yourmvi.com 
November 14, 2026
The purchase of 700 Meldon Ave. will lead to a new location for Dollar General. Donora Council selected bidders to sell one property and demolish another during Thursday’s meeting. Council unanimously...
GoFundMe set up for Monessen fire victim
Latest News, Main
By SARAH PELLIS spellis@yourmvi.com 
November 14, 2026
Alexa Lepresti’s dog is receiving veterinary care after being rescued. A fundraiser has been started for a Monessen resident whose house was badly damaged by fire. Monessen firefighters rescued Alexa ...
Groundbreaking today for credit union in Elizabeth Borough
Latest News, Main
By SARAH PELLIS spellis@yourmvi.com 
November 14, 2026
Steel Strong is moving to the former Rite Aid location in Elizabeth Borough. An old building is getting new life in the Mon Valley. The former Rite Aid at 300 Market St. in Elizabeth Borough was purch...