Author examines scary local legend
Latest News
October 26, 2020

Author examines scary local legend

By Mon Valley Independent

By ERIC SEIVERLING

eseiverling@yourmvi.com

With Halloween around the corner, people are looking for scary stories and frightening folklore to add enjoyment to the season.

But what if those stories were true, and not made-up myths?

In his new book, “The Witch of the Monongahela: Folk Magic in Early Western Pennsylvania,” author Thomas White separates fact from fiction, including the tale of Moll Derry, a mysterious figure who resided in Fayette County more than 200 years ago.

According to folklore, people came from near and far to seek healing and protection through Derry’s strange rituals. Some even believed she could fly. 

Nicknamed “The Witch of the Monongahela,” her legend has been documented by writers and folklorists for more than two centuries. She is intertwined in many regional tales, such as “Lost Children of the Alleghenies” and “Polly Williams and the White Rocks.”

According to White, archivist and curator of special collections in the Gumberg Library at Duquesne University, Derry’s tale isn’t totally fictitious.

“I wanted to delve into her legend to find out what’s true and what’s legend,” White said. “I knew parts of it couldn’t be true. 

“But she really was a real person. She was a fortune teller. What I found is her story is the combination of three different witches. What’s not true for her was true for someone else. The stories kind of got inflated over time by the mid-20th century.”

To read the rest of the story, please see a copy of Tuesday’s Mon Valley Independent, call 724-314-0035 to subscribe or subscribe to our online edition at http://monvalleyindependent.com.

SA grad Pikula hits another milestone at IUP
Sports
VALLEY PIPELINE
By JEREMY SELLEW 
April 6, 2026
The former Gladiator star notched her 200th career hit with the Crimson Hawks. IUP’s Madison Pikula continues to show why she was one of the most prolific softball players to come out of the Mon Valle...
’Burgh sports zip into a 180
Sports
SPORTLIGHT
By By JEFF OLIVER MVI Sports 
April 6, 2026
You can call me a homer if you want, but what I’m about to say is based more on fact than sentimentality. Name for me one other professional sports city whose fortunes have made a quicker about-face t...
O’Hearn homers, drives in four as Bucs sweep Orioles
Sports
By By KEVIN GORMAN TribLive 
April 6, 2026
What the Pittsburgh Pirates lacked more than pop in the middle of the lineup last season was the synergy to support a strong starting pitching performance. Braxton Ashcraft got both as he recorded a c...
Sports
April 6, 2026
Registration open for Steel City hoops Any players interested in playing in the premier girls summer basketball league can still register for the Steel City SBL until May 1. The league is open to play...
Extra
April 6, 2026
TEHRAN, Iran (AP) — U.S. President Donald Trump on Sunday made expletive-filled threats against Iran and its infrastructure if it doesn’t open the Strait of Hormuz by his Tuesday deadline, after Ameri...